Basics
Wargaming 101
This page gives the basics of wargaming: a definition, what a wargame teaches, its history and the air tasking cycle.
Definition
The Air Force Wargaming Institute (AFWI) at the LeMay Center, Maxwell Air Force Base, gives a definition.
“a unique interactive research model using purposefully selected game participants to generate data that does not already exist …”
Two ideas in that definition matter most. A wargame is interactive, and it makes data that did not exist before the game.
The institute also gives commanders a “laboratory environment”. There, they find problems in peacetime, before they face them in combat. For scientists and engineers, the idea is familiar: it is an experiment with people in the loop.
- Scenario
- Selected players
- Decisions
- Outcomes
- New data
All of it happens inside a laboratory environment.
What a wargame does not give
Lisle Babcock directs the Air Force Wargaming Institute. He says this:
“The wargame will never give you the solution.”
He also says what it does give you:
“What it gives you is the thought process to solve similar problems going forward.”
A wargame is also not a test of reflexes. In his words:
“You’re not in the cockpit, you’re not trying to avoid threats.”
Instead, you have time to think each decision through.
In a wargame, a mistake costs little, and you can learn from it.
History
- 1824
Prussia: Kriegsspiel
Georg von Reisswitz showed the Prussian General Staff a war game on maps, with rules, dice and an umpire. The army took it up to train officers.
- Between the wars
The Naval War College
The US Naval War College gamed a war with Japan again and again. In a 1960 address, Admiral Nimitz said that “nothing that happened during the war was a surprise”. He made one exception: the kamikaze tactics.
Historians call his remark an overstatement.
- Today
Digital wargames
The map table now also lives on a screen. It still has a map, rules and people who decide. The computer does the calculations of the umpire.
John Boyd and the OODA loop
John Boyd was a US Air Force fighter pilot. He described conflict as a loop: observe, orient, decide, act. People call it the OODA loop.
A common view is that the loop only means “be faster”. Boyd put the weight on orientation.
Orientation “is the most important part of the O O D A loop since it shapes the way we observe, the way we decide, the way we act.”
Orientation is how you make sense of what you see. Two people can see the same picture and do opposite things. In BattleTwin, the map shows you contacts, but you must decide what they mean.
- Observe
- Orient
- Decide
- Act
Wargaming 101 in January goes deeper. It adds Sun Tzu and Clausewitz.
The air tasking cycle
BattleTwin uses a background from public joint doctrine, in Joint Publication 3-30. An air operation runs on a cycle with six stages.
- Objectives, effects and guidance
- Target development
- Weaponeering and allocation
- Air tasking order production and dissemination
- Execution planning and force execution
- Assessment
Assessment feeds the next objectives, so the cycle is a loop. Stage names are from JP 3-30 (2019), a public release.
The air tasking order (ATO) tells each unit which missions to fly and when. One ATO normally covers 24 hours. Doctrine gives a planning cycle of 72 to 96 hours.
The loop never stops. On any day, units fly one ATO, while the staff plans the next ones and assesses an earlier one.
“The net result of the tasking process is a series of ATOs and related products in various stages of progress at any time.”
The cycle in the game
- Your plan
Before you press Begin, you choose the force and give first orders. Those orders are your tasking order for the day.
- The clock runs
When the clock runs, you are on the operations floor. You re-task your forces in the moment.
- The debrief
The debrief is your assessment of what worked. It feeds your next plan.
The game gives a simplified taste of the cycle, made for learning. It is not the real process.
The speaker's view
Future directions
An integrated picture
Wargaming is becoming one part of an integrated picture of the battlespace. It works with other models and simulations, each at its own level of fidelity.
Tabletop, digital and AI
Tabletop, digital and AI wargames all continue to have many different uses. Each one does a different job.
An AI co-commentator
We are building an AI co-commentator, the AI-MC, for the January event. It will watch every game and call the best moments.
The game engine stays the judge of every score. The AI only tells the story.